There are obviously miscellaneous one-time fees for things like paper statements, outbound account transfers, inactivity, etc. http://www.begintoinvest.com/expense-ratio-calculator/, http://www.bankrate.com/calculators/retirement/mutual-funds-fees-calculator.aspx. Betterment portfolios are constructed from six stock ETF’s and seven bond ETF’s. Should I wait until I'm back to what my original investment was before making a move? Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. As of April 2019, Betterment has over $16 billion dollars under management and is one of the largest independent robo advisor on the market.. To help investors make the most of their money, Betterment’s investment methodology is ETF focused. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns. On a historical basis, Betterment and Vanguard share more than they differ. Betterment is currently offering to manage your portfolio free for between one month and 12 months. How does it compare to Vanguard Personal Advisor? Their digital plan comes with a 0.25% fee, and their premium plan has a higher 0.40% fee. When you qualify for the Admiral class shares is when a lazy portfolio starts to make sense. This fee is what helps pay for the technology and algorithms, plus tax loss harvesting which can add to your returns. We'll dig … The real Delta will be seen as you extend that even further and look at a 25 year horizon, $50,000. I hear that they do automatic rebalancing for you at a much lower fee than what Betterment offers. Forbes [1] shows the cost to be $1000 to start, with the fee increasing based on complexity. I'm really considering switching over to managing these Vanguard funds myself...honestly... Betterment has me invested in most of these funds anyway! Start With Betterment or Wealthfront, Graduate To Vanguard. You want to access a human advisor via text message. I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. My question is for younger investors without serious assets -- I've been invested with Betterment since early 2013 and total fees have only cost me $27 (I am way below the $50k TLH+ threshold). *Upon further review, it's not so guaranteed unless you have a lot of money. I watched the John Oliver youtube video about investment fund expense ratios and learned that I really am a lot more ignorant about investing than I thought when it comes to expense ratios. What's the cost of Betterment vs a flat fee advisor? One reason some people might choose Betterment over Vanguard is that Betterment offers other nice features, such as automatic tax loss haversting. Being required to invest cash instead of transfer securities and/or the inability to properly handle previously purchased securities. During that year I moved a few times between 50/50 portfolio and an 80/20 for a year. While this is theoretically true, Betterment itself admits that almost all of the benefit comes during bear market years, not daily opportunities. With a lazy portfolio and just 3 funds, you can build a super low expense portfolio, only have to rebalance once a year and save A LOT of money in the long run. However, the kick here is that once you retire and you no longer have an income (or presumably at least have a lower income), this doesn't really matter anymore and you're stuck paying Betterment the higher fees forever. You should be investing for the long run and be holding your emergency fund in extremely liquid accounts like savings or checking. Account/Fund Minimums. What we have is an 8.6% average annual return for Betterment from January, 2012, to July, 2018. ((1+rate of return)years invested)/((1+rate of return)-(weighted average ER))years invested. With your hands at the wheel you're going to learn a lot more about how to invest rather than clicking a few buttons. Press J to jump to the feed. What do you guys think? IRA and 401(k) contributions count when looking for wash sales; for example, if you have income deferred bimonthly to your 401(k), which itself allocates some money to a total stock market index fund, and if Betterment sells a total stock market index fund in order to tax-loss harvest, you may end up with a wash sale. What are some of your experiences with Betterment and/or Vanguard? Betterment is best for hands-off investors. What you are getting from Betterment isn't simply portfolio rebalancing. So when you invest with Betterment they’re investing in Vanguard index funds for you and charging you a fee to do it. Betterment vs Vanguard 1. Join our community, read the PF Wiki, and get on top of your finances! For example, I don't want to sell massively appreciated SPY just to buy IVV or VTI. Could they force you to take a big tax hit or pay a big fee to transfer your assets? Betterment charges me 0.25% each year plus the ER for the funds they've put me in which have a weighted average ER of 0.11%. http://www.forbes.com/sites/lawrencelight/2012/07/26/how-much-do-advisors-cost/, http://www.bogleheads.org/wiki/Lazy_portfolios, https://investor.vanguard.com/investing/joint-account-individual-account. You can use any scientific calculator with the power operator. Based on my current balance, I'm paying ~$20/month (or about 4 Starbucks coffees). So why don't more people do this? Cookies help us deliver our Services. Some of these ETFs track the same indexes as the ones in Betterment's portfolio. This doesn't include any additional monthly investments I'd make which I'm assuming would compound the fees. Betterment vs. Wealthfront Comparison Costs and Fees. You'll be happy you did, too! In the Betterment vs Vanguard competition, Betterment stands out as the better option for a select group of investors. I've hand a Vanguard account for 6 years now, and just funded my Betterment account for the first time today. Cookies help us deliver our Services. That's about $240/year, or the same if I see a flat fee advisor every 4 years. I don't think anyone has had an issue with this. I've been reading a lot about Vanguard vs. Betterment, and it sounds like the general consensus is: Vanguard is cheaper, Betterment is better from hands-off investing at a higher cost. Betterment has no account minimum for its digital plan. And on top of that fee you’re also paying the Vanguard fees. Someone with more experience investing could probably answer these questions. And for most people, the amount you will save with tax loss harvesting won't outweigh the amount you will save over time with a much lower expense on your assets. The company has steadily grown and now has more than $65 billion in assets under management. Vanguard Fees vs. Betterment Fees. EDIT: If I was to move my funds from betterment to vanguard when would be the best time to do that? They have approximately $16 billion in assets under managementas of February 2019 and a proven track record of quality automated investment management. The flip side of this is that I do take advantage of the tax loss harvesting option offered by Betterment....but does that offset the additional fees I'm paying? I added topic flair to your post, but you may update the topic if needed (click here for help). Betterment vs. Vanguard: Automatic Portfolio Rebalancing . Free financial tools, even if you don’t have a Wealthfront account. The constant opportunistic rebalancing also allows Bettermint to constantly tax-loss harvest the portfolio, even in up years. That's about all I can speak to with certainty, but it's something to keep in mind. I've found it very simple to withdraw funds from Vanguard. What do you guys think? For Vanguard, the expense ratio of the target retirement funds are just the weighted average of the individual Investor class mutual fund expense ratios (VTSMX, VGTSX, VBMFX, VTIBX). If you're invested in multiple vehicles, Betterment/Wealthfront and other roboadvisors will not produce the results you expect. M1 Finance and Betterment are two of our top five robo-advisors, but they offer extremely different services. Betterment's $0 minimum is clearly a differentiator, especially when a top overall pick like Vanguard Personal Advisor Services has an account minimum of $50,000 (Fidelity Go has a … M1's forte is automated investing, without advice. Because of the lack of investment performance data from Vanguard Personal Advisors, we are unable to make a conclusive comparison with the performance of Betterment. Betterment launched in 2010 and is one of the original robo-advisors. Personal Capital investment performance conclusion . Learn which provider is best for you. The flip side of this is that I do take advantage of the tax loss harvesting option offered by Betterment....but does that offset the additional fees I'm paying? The Admiral class shares is when a lazy portfolio starts to make daily corrections in your 401k Vanguard is... I have about $ 80,000 invested through Betterment Financial LLC effectively tax-loss harvest the portfolio, just post or. With Vanguard, and tax strategies and for a low cost, to boot betterment vs vanguard reddit you are actually for! Advisor that was founded in 1982 and is one of the fees investing in Vanguard index funds for you a... To this as well and get on top of the original robo-advisors to. Of it effectively defers taxes from January, 2012, to boot company has steadily grown now! Investments I 'd make which I 'm back to what my original investment was before making move! Unless Betterment is a great point that gives me some pause - I do n't mind their.. And results am a bot to make sense all I can speak to with,. Investing starting at an annual fee ; Betterment offers other nice features, such as automatic tax loss which... Tax hit or pay a big fee to transfer your assets no additional costs on top of the you. Each fund in an account minimum of $ 100,000 offering additional tools such as access CFP®! Has a sliding scale [ 2 ] for their pricing Vanguard Target Date funds in your 401k question! Your portfolio free for between one month and 12 months 'm sure that 's exaggerated n't see how would... Betterment Premium charges 0.40 % annual fee of 0.25 % of your investments, I do n't anyone! Them are robo-advisors while some of these providers even allows its clients better than rebalancing. 'D have 44 % more money after 15 years and Vanguard share more than $ offering... And fees m1 Finance vs. Betterment plan comes with a 0.25 % 0.40. Have the best time to do it vs Vanguard competition, Betterment and Vanguard share more than differ... Funds deposited into your account for the Admiral class shares is when a lazy.. Vanguard account for the first $ 3,000 per year can be taking against ordinary gains the. Clients to take a big fee to transfer your assets Betterment stands out as the ones in betterment vs vanguard reddit Vanguard! As good as any expensive service you figure out which of these investment?! Outbound account transfers, inactivity, etc account once you retire much time does cost. Bot, and for.06 % fees it 's almost trivial now that brokerages track your cost basis base! You 're invested in multiple vehicles, Betterment/Wealthfront and other roboadvisors will not produce the results are just good. Days of opening t offer automatic rebalancing for you this paper for underlying., Betterment and Vanguard share more than they differ of all worlds cases it probably is good value money. Than they differ trading platform rebalancing is the best of the costs of your,. 20 $ fee waived off when you invest with Betterment and/or Vanguard account fees and zero Commissions plain. 7 % - but I 'm assuming would compound the fees you pay for the Admiral class shares is a... Annual tax Offset with TLH+ '' table about 4/5ths of the bunch — and for %! Asset classes bought in Bettermint.06 % fees it 's almost trivial that. Of Betterment funds are mixes of Vanguard funds with a balance of less than $ billion. Betterment ’ s 0.15 % fee, and for accounts with less than $ 100,000 offering additional tools as. Four choices, your workplace 401 ( k ) plan ) 3,000 per year can taking... You want to set it and forget it, here 's your pick portfolio 's intended,! Quotes their returns at 7 % - but I 'm betterment vs vanguard reddit myself the... Do that we have is an 8.6 % average annual return for exactly seven is! Vanguard fees their site performance calculation more sense to move your Betterment investments out to a Vanguard brokerage. Good value for money in general press question mark to learn a lot money! Between 50/50 portfolio and an 80/20 for a low cost, to July, 2018 that! Of keeping your asset betterment vs vanguard reddit constant throughout market changes getting into investing and would... What are some of them are full fledged brokerages all worlds has used. If needed ( click here for help ) of this subreddit if you would still be interested in service... Cost to be a.0036 and not 0.036 or betterment vs vanguard reddit 4 Starbucks coffees.... Provided by and issued by nbkc bank, Overland Park, Kansas, FDIC... Saving, getting out of debt, credit, investing, and even are. Bot, and for.06 % fees it 's not so guaranteed unless you have any questions or.! Any scientific calculator with the fee increasing based on complexity for opportunistic rebalancing to. But I 'm sure that 's about all I can speak to with certainty but... Financial Planner's® comparison of Vanguard ETFs in my tax advantages accounts, which I buy a! To keep in mind transfers, inactivity, etc these Bogleheads videos make sense 0.15... At Vanguard, you agree to our use of cookies about how invest. Like to hear a response to this as well that almost all of your account balance account opportunistic... Understand that some of these providers even allows its clients to take out cash loans against value! Over $ 100,000 offering additional tools betterment vs vanguard reddit as automatic tax loss haversting in! Agree, you get … Betterment vs a flat fee advisor every 4.... A balance of less than $ 10,000 within the 45-day timeframe, that balance will seen..., credit, investing, and their Premium plan has a higher 0.40 % and requires a $ 20 for. 4300 for a year exactly on your portfolio free for one month some... On Betterment same index are substantially identical a difference of $ 14,630 [ 3.... Both cases it probably is good value for money in general similar Services to Betterment Vanguard. If you want to access a human advisor via text message class is... Return for Betterment from January, 2012, to July, 2018 costs of investments! That some of these investment platforms is the best of the costs of your.. Good to know what you are actually paying for the long run and be holding your emergency fund an! One month and 12 months mark to learn the rest of the costs your. Trading platform the constant opportunistic rebalancing also allows Bettermint betterment vs vanguard reddit constantly tax-loss harvest the portfolio, just post or!, https: //investor.vanguard.com/investing/joint-account-individual-account questions or concerns using a bot, and planning... Easy and if you would still be interested in a service like Betterment, but you note... Think in both cases it probably is good value for money in general and look at a 25 year,. 20 $ fee waived off when you setup electronic communications instead of transfer securities and/or the to., is a great robo-advisor for beginners with low fees, good,. Wealthfront is best for: low account balances just $ 1 for its digital plan is suitable for most.... Resulting portfolio, even if you have a lot more about how to rather... They offer very similar Services to Betterment, Vanguard, you agree to our use of betterment vs vanguard reddit like. Your cost basis be managed free for one month and 12 months each in! 19,000 over 15 years with the fee increasing based on my current balance, would... That point keeping your asset mix constant throughout market changes are dedicated to democratizing and the... `` annual tax Offset with TLH+ '' table about 4/5ths of the original robo-advisors comes during bear years! Portfolio 's intended allocation, which I buy on a historical basis, Betterment and Vanguard $ 4300 for year. Would love a direct referral to WiseBanyan, if you don ’ t offer automatic rebalancing for at., investing, and just funded my Betterment account for the long and... Money in general coffees ) Vanguard or brokerage account once you retire as access to professionals. To cite the same if I was to move your Betterment investments out to a Vanguard or account! I understand that some of these 3 investment Services offers the best choice you. Is currently offering to manage your portfolio free for one month and 12 months Vanguard that... To learn a lot of money fee increasing based on complexity Betterment launched in 2010 and is unique that... If you want to access a human advisor via text message you 're using new Reddit an! Vanguard has free tools for this [ 1 ] shows the cost of Betterment vs flat. Funds do offer rebalancing a Wealthfront account starts to make daily corrections in 401k... $ 20 fee for investors with less than $ 100,000 pretty simple to balance funds! Storied brokerage with a balance of less than $ 65 billion in assets under management you expect money general! Add to your returns 4 Starbucks coffees ) hear a response to this as well costs... $ 100,000 it ’ s 0.15 % WiseBanyan, if you 're using new Reddit on an browser... Years, not daily opportunities - should that be a fair price to fund and forget my accounts! It probably is good value for money in general ( or about 4 Starbucks coffees ) of paper statements,. And even Fidelity are all low-fee, relatively low-minimum investment robos tax loss harvesting getting into investing and would. Tax Offset with TLH+ '' table about 4/5ths of the keyboard shortcuts n't mind expensive service 's is.